Latest
Woman killed in Times Square stabbing, suspect shot dead by police‘Start being serious’: Canada’s Carney hits back at US officials as tariff talks stall – liveFairness for growers is food security for AmericaGOP hardliners threaten rebellion over stopgap funding billMicrosoft 365 outage drags on, but things are improvingOlivia Rodrigo is standing up for the vulnerable. I wish Taylor Swift would do the same | Arwa MahdawiShelly’s new $50 security camera watches your home without a subscriptionWoman killed in Times Square stabbing, suspect shot dead by police‘Start being serious’: Canada’s Carney hits back at US officials as tariff talks stall – liveFairness for growers is food security for AmericaGOP hardliners threaten rebellion over stopgap funding billMicrosoft 365 outage drags on, but things are improvingOlivia Rodrigo is standing up for the vulnerable. I wish Taylor Swift would do the same | Arwa MahdawiShelly’s new $50 security camera watches your home without a subscription
← Top America

Judge orders continued deliberations in Lindsay Clancy trial as jury reaches deadlock

Confirmed1 source · Sep 1, 2026

A Massachusetts jury deliberating the case of a former nurse accused of killing her three children has reached an impasse on its fourth day, prompting the judge to order further discussions.

Judge orders continued deliberations in Lindsay Clancy trial as jury reaches deadlock
Image via The Guardian

What happened

A jury in the Lindsay Clancy trial reported being unable to reach a unanimous decision on Tuesday, the fourth day of deliberations. The judge instructed jurors to continue deliberating. Clancy, 36, a former labor and delivery nurse, does not deny strangling her three children but pleads not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility, claiming postpartum psychosis impaired her mental state. Prosecutors argue she acted with full knowledge of her actions, characterizing her motive as depression and a desire to end her life. The jury can choose between convicting her of murder, convicting her of manslaughter, or acquitting her if they believe her mental health was the determining factor.

Context

The verdict carries significant consequences: conviction on murder charges could result in a life sentence, while acquittal does not guarantee freedom—a judge could order her confined to a mental health facility if she is deemed dangerous. The case hinges on whether Clancy retained sufficient mental capacity under Massachusetts law to appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct. Clancy had sought psychiatric treatment in the months before the killings, including a hospital stay, and had been prescribed 13 different sleep and anxiety medications. Beyond the criminal trial, Clancy and her former husband Patrick have filed a civil malpractice suit against her healthcare providers, alleging they failed to properly diagnose, treat, and monitor her postpartum psychiatric condition.

What's disputed

Whether Clancy's actions resulted from postpartum psychosis rendering her unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of killing her children (defense position) or from conscious deliberation driven by depression and suicidal intent (prosecution position).